Jul 16 2009
EdTech – Stop kidding yourself
Why is it that as educational technologists we feel the need to stand on our digital soapboxes and scream, “You’re not doing enough! You’re not trying all the new things! How can you be a good educator unless you do? Think about the children!” It seems the thin air of the digital tower we live in is getting to us. I have read posting after posting pontificating the woeful state of educational technology because teachers and admininstrators do not share our passion and priority for integrating technology solutions into the curriculum. Parents say “we need more computer education!” without having an understanding of why and for what. Adminstrations see the number of computers and amount of hardware you have as a badge of technology education success. Yes, I do want an excellent education for my children…so prove to me what you’re spouting will do that.
Explain to me how learning how to use Twitter in the classroom will help my child become a better researcher. Explain to me how blogging will teach them better writing skills. Demonstrate to me how using the latest and greatest web solutions will help them in 10 years when they graduate and 90% of those systems don’t exist anymore. Face it…there isn’t a system we will teach them today that won’t be obsolete by the time they are ready to use it professionally. Stop kidding yourself if you think otherwise (see Moore’s Law for reference). Get back to focusing on the skills derived from the systems, not the systems themselves. Look at the yearly Science Fair presentation displays. The cardboard backboards come out, letters are cut out and glued, and the display is ready. But for some reason now it’s a “better” presentation if it includes a laptop with a multimedia presentation about the experiment. Is the experiment more scientifically sound because it’s presented with stereo audio and dissolving transitions? I can’t help but smile everytime I see a student without a “multimedia extravaganza” take a higher place in the competition over one or more that do. Show me a student who can articulate their work without digital assistance and I’ll show you one I would hire.
Do you want an easy test to see if you’re doing your job? Teach the students how to build a great presentation on a topic, researched on the Internet, with embedded video and audio, graphic representations of the topics involved, all encapsulated for easy delivery. Then turn off the projector and make them deliver the material. If they can’t…you failed, not them. So often I see the teachers who are highly competent to present in front of an audience of students (where they have control) turn to mush when in front of their peers. Is it because they don’t have an LCD projector or SmartBoard to “carry” their presentation or is it that somewhere along the line a teacher failed to prepare them properly?
Stop being a computer geek and start focusing on the needs over the hows. Students NEED to be able to present comfortably. They don’t NEED to know how to use PowerPoint 2007 to do that. Students NEED to develop writing and critical thinking skills. They don’t NEED to use Wordpress 2.8 to accomplish that just because it’s not Wordpress 2.7 and has a new feature or two. Want another great example? Check out any of the videos by Creative Commons. Exceptionally well done with strong information sources and a smooth topical delivery. THEY WERE DONE WITH PAPER AND MARKER! Impress your students with skills that work with or without technology. Don’t let yourself become the “Twitter teacher” because you’re then nothing more than a “Twit”. I will never stop advocating there is a place for technology in the school and the classroom. But I will also never stop saying it has a time and a place and that isn’t all the time and everywhere.
Do your teachers and staff have the tools necessary to work together as a team? Considering building an intranet? That’s what we’re doing and I’ll explain how. The amount of power and functionality that a school has access to through a system such as Google Apps gives a great opportunity to build a collaborative workspace for teachers and staff with virtually no cost. However the idea isn’t without it’s challenges. When planning any sort of collaborative web effort, I recommend starting with three key questions:
As the summer quickly slips by thoughts of lesson planning and lesson plans creep into the minds of teachers as the look towards the fall. Here are some thoughts and suggestions on how you can apply Google Docs to make your lesson plans easier to manage, maintain, and use during the coming school year.